Cock Robin

(*warning* - Zahmawh content)
This is slightly different, you're told the answer, and you guess the question. The question-that-is-the-answer is just a few lines below, but you can try to let your honest side, if you have any, win and try to answer it without looking at the answer, and tell me what your answers were.

So the answer is ---- 'Cock Robin.'

Sohna's first answer was 'Who killed some bird or the other?,' she then changed it to 'Cock Robin is the one that died?' referring to this nursery rhyme. Shirley's one and only answer was 'What was the name of Jack Robinson's chicken?'

Anyway, without further ado, the question is - "What's that you put in my mouth, Batman?!"

:-)

Generally, this should resolve the 'Is Robin/Batman gay?' debate. Forever. (Ref - the last comment on this old post of mine.)